Robert dreams of walking through the woods with James and they discuss what happened the day Bellamy first died. Mr. Henderson walks out of the woods in complete panic and though Bellamy tries to assure him that he is fine, he begs to be taken back. When Bellamy awakes, he tells Maggie about the dream he had about James and she encourages him to speak to him. Bellamy is still uncertain, sure in his belief that Janes has an angle. Realising that Bellamy and Maggie are talking about Preacher James, Jenny tells them the story of how Preacher James healed a man, giving him the ability to walk. Bellamy becomes certain that James is a con man when Jenny reveals that at James's sermons, there was always a collection plate.
Henry and Fred are having breakfast together and they discuss the fight that Lucille and Henry are having. Henry asks for advice on the situation and Fred brings up the factory but Henry declares that it is about the Langston legacy. In frustration, Fred tells Henry that he doesn't want to hear the truth because the factory was about their mother. Fred believes that what happened with factory made Lucille believe that Margaret was more important to Henry than her and Jacob. Henry wonders if Margaret is okay.
Margaret makes her way into the dining room of the facility and all of the resident stop speaking. Margaret is clearly disturbed. In the corner, a woman is bullied out of her glasses and Margaret intervenes and demands that the glasses be returned. After pausing for a moment, the bully hands Margaret the glasses and she returns them to the owner before sitting and returning to her meal
Jacob and Lucille walk hand in hand and Jacob wonders when his father is coming home. Lucille assures Jacob that what is going on has nothing to do with him and that he can see Henry whenever he wants. Jacob then sees Jenny and Bellamy walking down the street and the two kids run off together. Across the street, Lucille notices a crowd of people gathered together. It turns out that Preacher James is giving a sermon on the street corner. James fixates on Mrs. Henderson, who is in mourning for her husband. James tells Mrs. Henderson that she has to believe in a miracle and sure enough, Mr. Henderson arrives.
At the hospital, Rachel arrives because she is experiencing contractions. Rachel explains everything that happened with Janine and her daring escape to Maggie, who suggests informing Fred but Rachel makes it clear that she is not afraid of Janine. It turns out that what Rachel was experiencing was Braxton Hicks contractions but her pregnancy is moving rapidly forward. Maggie promises Rachel that she will find her a place to stay and Rachel is adamant that she wants to pay her own way and does not want charity.
Bellamy walks into the local bar and finds Pastor James. James reveals that he was asked to bring Tom back from the dead and says that unfortunately, he couldn't oblige. Bellamy tells James that he couldn't bring Tom back because it is not in his power to do so. James brings up their shared dream and Bellamy asserts that Mrs. Henderson was conned into believing that James brought her husband back. James declares that he did bring Mr. Henderson back and that Henderson called out for help, which James provided. Bellamy then reveals that he knows that James was a con artist in his past life but James questions how Bellamy can continue to doubt, given the miracles he has seen. James questions what he has to do to make Bellamy believe and in return, Bellamy threatens him with the government holding center for the Returned, if James continues to con people.
Henry is in Fred's spare room and he breaks down and calls Lucile. Henry asks to get together to talk and they agree to meet at Twain's for dinner at 6pm tonight.
Back at the facility, Robin, the woman whose glasses Margaret returned, enters Margaret's room. Robin reveals that she knows who Margaret is and that her uncle worked at Langston furniture. Robin thanks Margaret for what she did and Margaret says that she has always known how to handle bullies. When Robin suggests that the bullies are afraid of Margaret, Margaret says that they should be. Robin then brings up Richard and asks if Margaret killed him but Margaret instead changes the topic and simply says that she can be thanked by being left alone. Instead of leaving, Robin informs Margaret that there are Returned who want to escape and begs Margaret for help but Margaret reveals that she has no desire to leave the facility.
Lucille is waiting at the restaurant for Henry. Bellamy sits in his office and Henry suddenly appears to thank Bellamy for returning Jacob to him. Fred knocks on the door to ask if Bellamy wants some Indian food and Bellamy is quick to turn that down. When Bellamy turns around, Henry is gone. Henry and Fred rush outside to find Henry dead in his SUV. Later, Henry lies on a stretcher, as Fred tells Bellamy that because he is the youngest, he doesn't know a life without Henry. Fred is wracked with guilt because he tried to have Jacob taken away, adding that Henry forgave him. Bellamy tries to assure Fred that he made up for it but Fred believes he has not. Bellamy gives Fred a comforting tap before heading to a crying Maggie. Maggie brings up the fact that Henry spent 30 years grieving Jacob adding that she finds it incredibly sad that now that Jacob has returned, Henry is dead. Maggie believes that Henry died of a sudden cardiac arrest like his father. When Maggie finally completely breaks down, Bellamy embraces her.
